Navigating the U.S. Asylum Process: A Beginner’s Guide

Hispanic family - potential beneficiaries of U.S. Asylum Process
Welcome to the Rodriguez | Marrero Law Firm blog! If you or a loved one are seeking refuge in the United States due to persecution in your home country, understanding the U.S. asylum process is critical. This post breaks down the U.S. asylum process, outlining affirmative and defensive asylum procedures. Additionally, we illuminate key contrasts between these paths and emphasize the importance of securing legal representation for a successful outcome.

The U.S. Asylum Process: An Overview

If you are fleeing persecution, understanding the U.S. asylum process is vital.  The U.S. asylum process provides protection to foreign nationals who have suffered persecution in their home countries.  Moreover, it provides a path to safety for those who have a well-founded fear of persecution. This persecution may be based on factors such as race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion.  Asylum seekers must demonstrate their eligibility through one of two main routes: affirmative asylum and defensive asylum.

Affirmative Asylum Process

Affirmative asylum is the process through which an individual who is not in removal proceedings applies for asylum in the U.S.  This process takes place directly with the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). The key steps in this process include:
  1. File the Application: First, asylum seekers must file Form I-589, Application for Asylum and for Withholding of Removal, along with supporting documentation, within one year of their most recent entry into the U.S.
  2. Attend Biometrics Appointment: Secondly, applicants attend a biometrics appointment where fingerprints and photographs are taken for background checks.
  3. Undergo Interview: Next, a USCIS asylum officer tests your claim’s credibility and analyzes all the information you presented through an in-depth interview.
  4. Decision: Finally, the officer makes a decision based on the interview and evidence—grant asylum, deny the application, or refer the case to immigration court for removal proceedings.

Defensive Asylum Process

Defensive asylum is pursued when an individual is in removal proceedings before an immigration judge.  This typically happens when an individual is apprehended at the U.S. border or is already in the U.S. and faces deportation.  The Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR), which is part of the U.S. Department of of Justice, oversees all immigration court proceedings. The process involves:
  1. Attend Master Calendar Hearing(s): First, the individual, also known as the “Respondent,” appears before an immigration judge for an initial hearing to establish their intent to seek asylum.
  2. Prepare for and Attend Individual Hearing: Next, the judge the attorneys conduct a more comprehensive hearing where you present evidence, witnesses, and legal arguments to support your asylum claim.
  3. Judge Makes Decision: Finally, the immigration judge renders a decision on the asylum application. If granted, the individual can stay in the U.S. If denied, the judge may issue a deportation order.  Alternatively, you or your attorney may ask the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) to review the judge’s decision.

Key Differences Between Affirmative and Defensive Asylum

Though both paths pursue asylum status, critical differences distinguish affirmative and defensive processes:
  • Timing: Affirmative asylum is initiated outside the immigration court system, while defensive asylum takes place within the court system during removal proceedings.
  • Applicant’s Role: In affirmative cases, the applicant (ideally, after having prepared with their attorney) presents their case to USCIS. In defensive cases, the applicant’s attorney plays a more prominent role in presenting evidence and arguments to the immigration judge.

The Importance of Legal Representation

As highlighted previously on this blog, the asylum process’s complexity and challenges warrant expert legal assistance. Engaging legal representation reaps several benefits, including:
  1. Expertise: Experienced immigration attorneys understand the nuances of asylum law, increasing the chances of a successful outcome.
  2. Documentation: Attorneys assist in compiling a compelling case by gathering and presenting essential evidence.
  3. Advocacy: Attorneys advocate on behalf of the applicant, ensuring their rights are protected throughout the process.
  4. Preparation: Attorneys thoroughly prepare applicants for interviews and court appearances, boosting their confidence and credibility.


Successfully navigating the U.S. asylum process requires a clear understanding of both affirmative and defensive asylum procedures. Regardless of the path chosen, enlisting the support of skilled legal professionals can make a significant difference. Attorney Emilio José Rodríguez is dedicated to guiding you through the complexities of the asylum process and helping you secure the protection you deserve. Contact us today to learn how we can assist you on this critical journey.

Looking For Reliable & Dedicated Legal Representation?